Problem: A student measures an enzyme's rate with and without a drug. Without the drug: rate 50.0 at [S] = 20 and 90.0 at [S] = 180. With the drug: rate 33.3 at [S] = 20 and 81.8 at [S] = 180. Is the drug a competitive or a noncompetitive inhibitor?
Step 1: Compare at low [S]. 33.3/50.0=0.67. The drug cuts the rate by about a third.
Step 2: Compare at high [S]. 81.8/90.0=0.91. The drug now cuts the rate by less than a tenth.
Step 3: Interpret. The inhibition weakens as [S] rises, so substrate is outcompeting the drug for the active site. That is competitive inhibition. A noncompetitive inhibitor would remove the same fraction of activity at every [S], because extra substrate cannot reverse the shape change.
Check it in the simulator: choose Competitive and set [S] to 20; the rate reads 33.3. Move to 180 and it reads 81.8, close to the faded uninhibited curve. Now choose Noncompetitive. At [S] = 20 the rate is 25.0 and at 180 it is 45.0, exactly half the uninhibited values of 50.0 and 90.0 at both concentrations.